|
These are hard
times for
child’s play:
•Testing
pressures have
squeezed much
of the play
out of
kindergarten,
according to
many activists
and
researchers.
And those
pressures are
even trickling
down to
preschools.
•Parents
worried about
their
children’s
safety — and
maybe
hankering for
some time to
themselves —
keep them
indoors, often
tethered to a
television, a
computer or a
video game.
•And
children’s
toys — and
their fantasy
lives — run
heavily toward
licensed
characters
derived from
videos and
television
programs
created in
someone else’s
imagination.
All of
which is to
say: Whatever
happened to
making mud
pies?
Incrementally
and almost
imperceptibly,
“we have
completely
changed the
way children
play,” said
Dimitri
Christakis, a
pediatrician
and director
of the Child
Health
Institute at
the University
of Washington.
Christakis
studies
children’s use
of media, and
he is part of
a rising tide
of concern
about the
altered
landscape of
children’s
play. “We’re
in the midst
of a large,
uncontrolled
experiment on
our children,”
he said, “the
effects of
which we won’t
know for
years.”
What is
known is that
the kind of
open-ended,
hands-on,
imaginative
and often
outdoor play
that has been
vanishing is
critical to
young
children’s
development,
said Susan
Linn, a
psychologist
at the Judge
Baker
Children’s
Center, a
research,
advocacy and
clinical unit
affiliated
with Harvard
University.
She’s working
on a book that
she describes
as “a
celebration of
and plea for”
imaginative
play.
Some of the
results of
this new era
in children’s
play are
well-documented.
Childhood
obesity, for
example.
Others are
more
anecdotal:
children who
“don’t know”
what to do
when left to
their own
devices. Or
who are burned
out on school
by the fourth
grade.
At the same
time,
preliminary
research
suggests that
a few small
efforts by
parks
districts,
zoos and
botanical
gardens across
the country
are showing
the way to put
the power back
in play.
•••
Children’s
play has been
extensively
studied, and
its value is
beyond
dispute,
according to
Linn.
“Play is
the foundation
of critical
thinking, the
foundation of
creativity,
the foundation
of learning,”
she said.
“Imaginary
play is also a
way that
children make
emotional and
social meaning
of the world.
I think a
majority of
the country
doesn’t know
we have a
problem, and
they’re being
sold a bill of
goods by
policy-makers
and the
marketing
industry.”
A nonprofit
organization
called the
Alliance for
Childhood is
funding
research into
the state of
play and plans
to agitate for
the return of
play to
schools. On
its Web site
is a “call to
action” signed
by 260 people,
including
luminaries
such as
pediatrician
and author T.
Berry
Brazelton and
writer and
children’s
advocate
Jonathan Kozol.
The
alliance also
is spreading
the word about
“adventure
playgrounds”
and
play-workers,
both
ubiquitous in
England, and
is working
with museums
to mount
exhibits on
the now-hot
topic of
child’s play.
Although
children have
a natural gift
for and drive
to play, it
can evaporate
if not
exercised.
Several years
ago, the
alliance
surveyed
experienced
kindergarten
teachers in
Atlanta about
changes in
play in their
schools over
the preceding
decade.
Several
teachers
reported that
play largely
had been
eliminated
from class and
that if they
gave children
time for play,
“they don’t
know what to
do. They have
no ideas of
their own.’ ”
A guidance
counselor from
an elementary
school in
Virginia told
Joan Almon,
the alliance’s
president,
that a
first-grade
class was
baffled by the
term
“imagination.”
When the
counselor gave
them a
specific
example of her
own pretend
life as a
child, “not
one child in
the class knew
what she was
talking
about.”
•••
Prevailing
playground
design doesn’t
help much,
either.
“It’s
usually a
bunch of
manufactured
equipment in
an open space
devoid of any
meaningful
vegetation
that kids can
interact
with,” said
Randy White, a
partner in a
Kansas City
firm that
designs play
spaces. “They
need chances
to hide under
bushes and dam
up water and
build with
loose parts.
Children want
to manipulate
their
environment.”
White’s
firm, White
Hutchinson
Leisure &
Learning
Group, tries
to persuade
clients to
provide more
engaging play
options.
That’s finally
starting to
catch on in
the United
States, he
said.
In this
area, White
said, the
Wonderscope
Children’s
Museum in
Shawnee and
the Children’s
Museum in
Kansas City,
Kan., offer
some of the
better play
opportunities
for children.
Paradise Park
in Lee’s
Summit, a
commercial
playground
that his firm
designed, also
has some
interactive
features.
While
anecdotes
abound
concerning
play-challenged
children, hard
data are
scarce. But
then, it’s in
the nature of
the thing,
according to
Roger Hart,
who runs the
Children’s
Environments
Research
Center at the
City
University of
New York
Graduate
Center.
“People
haven’t found
a way to
measure
creativity,”
he said. “The
danger when
you get into a
hyper-testing
environment as
we have now is
that things …
get left
behind in the
dust, not
because
they’re not
important, but
because we
don’t know how
to measure
them.”
Not
surprisingly,
many of the
people worried
about the
state of
children’s
play are most
distressed
about the
warping
influence of
electronic
media. And the
media’s impact
goes beyond
the many hours
most children
spend in front
of a screen,
Linn said. She
pointed out
that the year
after
children’s
television was
deregulated in
the mid-1980s,
every one of
the
best-selling
toys was
linked to a
television
program.
“Kids play
less
creatively
with
media-linked
toys because
the character
has been
defined for
them,” said
Linn, who
wrote a book
titled
Consuming Kids
about
marketing
aimed at
children. Toys
that come with
an identity
and a story
line mean that
“the child
doesn’t have
to do anything
but push a
button. It’s
not limitless
possibilities
the way it is
when a child
picks up a
stick.
“It’s
funny, isn’t
it? It looks
like such an
advance.”
Sparks to
imagination
Despite cultural forces that have put a choke hold on children’s play,
there are
some
encouraging
developments.
Some
examples:
•Children
visiting the
Kansas City
Zoo have a
couple of
new
opportunities
for play,
and others
are on the
way.
Earlier
this summer
the zoo
opened the
Discovery
Barn in the
red barn
that had
housed farm
animals.
Children are
encouraged
to imitate
exotic
animals now
housed there
by climbing
on a log
like a
lemur, or
crawling
like a
squirrel
monkey
across a
cargo net
suspended
above the
floor.
Outside
the barn is
the peekaboo
tree, a
three-story
faux tree
with a
spiral
staircase
inside to
help kids
climb.
A tropics
building,
now being
designed,
will provide
opportunities
for
children,
perhaps to
make
rubbings
from faux
hieroglyphics.
Director
Randy
Wisthoff
said zoos
can fill a
critical
need.
“We all
believe it’s
very
important
for kids to
play and
pretend,” he
said. “A zoo
is supposed
to be
educational,
conservational
— and fun.”
For
details, go
to
www.kansascityzoo.org.
•Many
parents
don’t like
to think of
it as a
playground.
But Katie
Belisle-Iffrig
says the
Children’s
Garden that
opened in
April at the
Missouri
Botanical
Garden in
St. Louis
encourages
“curiosity
and
creativity
and provide
spaces for
them to
make-believe
in.”
The
2-acre
garden has
four
pathways,
each built
around a
historical
figure. A
wide range
of Missouri
ecosystems
is
represented,
and plants
are
emphasized.
“They’ll
plant the
vegetables
in the sand,
then dig ’em
up and take
them to a
place called
the general
store and
sell them,”
said
Belisle-Iffrig,
the garden
manager,
explaining
that “we try
to encourage
curiosity
and
creativity
and provide
spaces for
them to
make-believe
in.”
For more
details, go
to
www.mobot.org.
•Joe
Modrich
decided a
few years
ago that he
wanted to
“bring more
play into
children’s
lives” in
Franklin
Park, Ill.
Now, in
day camp
there, “we
take the
approach
that every
activity, if
it can be
child-led,
it should
be,” said
Modrich,
director of
parks and
recreation.
“If the kids
decide to
play
baseball, we
let them
make the
calls and
resolve the
arguments.”
It’s
working so
well that
Modrich has
been invited
to share his
approach
with nearby
school and
park
districts.
Imagine a
playground
where the
basic
equipment
includes
hammers,
saws,
abandoned
boats — and
nails.
Nails?
Adventure
playgrounds,
as they are
known, are
fixtures
throughout
Europe.
There are
two in the
United
States: in
Berkeley and
Huntington
Beach,
Calif.
At
Berkeley “we
give the
kids
hammers,
nails, saws
and paint
and lots of
recycled
wood” to
encourage
play, said
Patty
Donald, who
helped
establish
the
playground.
For more
information,
go to
www.ci.berkeley.ca.us/marina/marinaexp/adventplgd.html.
|